< Back to all blog posts
IP Management

Which Patents Should You Keep? Four Questions Before the Next Renewal

Imagine a subscription that you never use but still pay for every year. You would cancel it without a second thought.

Patents often get different treatment. A granted patent feels like an achievement, and cancelling it feels like admitting defeat. That is the trophy mindset. But a patent is a business tool, and a tool earns its place in the toolbox only while it does a job.

Here is a practical approach you can use in your next portfolio review.

Four questions for every patent

Ask them one patent at a time:

  1. Does it protect our core technology?
  2. Does it keep competitors out of a market that matters to us?
  3. Does it hold licensing or revenue potential?
  4. Does it strengthen our position in negotiations?

If all four answers are no, the patent is idle. Idle does not mean free. Maintenance fees, attorney costs, translations and the internal time spent reviewing the patent keep adding up, and every euro spent here is a euro not spent on stronger filings or more focused innovation.

Why teams hesitate

It is rarely a lack of skill. Usually it is missing visibility, and with it missing confidence. If nobody can show quickly what a patent contributes, letting it lapse feels like a risk.

Often the opposite is true. Concentrating your budget on the patents that do real work is a sign of a structured IP strategy, not of retreat.

Make it a routine, not a debate

Answering four questions from memory works for ten patents. It does not work for several hundred. You need the business relevance, the cost impact and the strategic value of each patent in one place.

That is what we built Patent Cockpit to show. With that picture in front of you, a renewal decision becomes a matter of evidence instead of gut feeling.

Fewer patents, better chosen

A smaller portfolio is not a weaker one if every patent has a reason to be there. Competitive advantage does not come from owning the most patents. It comes from patents that fit your business goals and from the discipline to drop the ones that do not.

The short version of the original idea is on LinkedIn.

Curious how your own portfolio would score? Book a call and we will look at it together.

< Back to all blog posts