Imagine three conversations about the same patent. The patent attorney talks about claims and a restriction requirement. The engineer talks about the latest experiment. The managing director asks one thing: is this money well spent?
Nobody is wrong. Nobody is careless. Yet the three of them hardly understand each other. In an SME, the person who has to bridge that gap is often the IP manager.
Here we look at the three-worlds problem from the seat of the person in the middle.
The legal world speaks in "characterized in that" and "preferably". It matters there, and it is often hard to follow from outside.
The technical world speaks in prototypes, test results and the next release. Engineers are absorbed in their creations, and rightly so, but the other two worlds easily slip out of view.
The business world speaks in KPIs and the big picture. It cannot work through every detail, so it needs a summary it can trust.
The three-body problem from physics is a good picture for what happens next. Three bodies that attract each other do not settle into a calm orbit. A tiny disturbance is enough to send them in very different directions.
In an IP portfolio, the disturbance can be a product change, a new office action or a budget cut. Each is small, and each shifts the other two worlds.
There are many periodic orbits known for the problem, but most of them are not stable. The animation below (Source) shows one that repeats: the blue product world is chased by the yellow legal world, and the business world circles both.
The IP manager moves between the worlds, collects information, translates it, and looks for compromises. Then comes the part that is easy to forget: making sure the compromise is actually carried out.
A perfectly stable system is probably out of reach. A system that is regularly corrected in small steps is not. That is the aim: keep the three worlds close enough that a disturbance does not send them apart.
Patent Cockpit is built to support exactly that routine. It brings the legal, technical and business view of the same rights into one place, so the small corrections are quick to make.
< Back to all blog posts